Flotilla | A probe that would get Netanyahu’s government off the hook

Posted: June 14th, 2010 | Author: | Filed under: In the News, the US and us | Tags: , , , , , , , , , , , , | 4 Comments »

“[the] commission’s conclusions were pre-determined… members of the panel did give the facts a chance to confuse them.”

(Israel’s Foreing Minister, Avigdor Lieberman, on the Goldston’s commission’s report)

“Gaza flotilla probe will show the world Israel acted lawfully.”

(PM Benjamin Netanayhu talking at the start of the cabinet meeting which unanimous approved the probe).

Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu announced today the forming of an investigative commission into the raid on the Gaza-bound flotilla. The commission will include three Israelis and two foreign observers. The internationals won’t be bale to vote on decisions or view confidential material.

The three Israeli members were carefully chosen so that they would suit Netanyahu’s political needs. The Prime Minister wishes to keep the government intact, and not have Defense Minister Ehud Barak forced to resign. It shouldn’t be too hard with Supreme Court justice Jacob Turkel heading the committee. Turkel explained his views of on such probe in an interview to the IDF radio three weeks:

“I don’t like personal recommendations. The main thing is what stands before me. I don’t want any more failures, and whether a certain person is dismissed or not, or whether his role is frozen or not is of secondary importance.”

Two elderly gentlemen will serve under Turkel:  93 years old international law professor Shabtai Rosen, and 86 years old Maj. Gen. (res.) Amos Horev, who has been know for his criticism on the army in the past, but will probably not put the political leadership in danger.

In order to take care of the international crisis, add some credibility to the committee and give the US something to justify backing it with, two international observers were added to the panel. The first is Lord David Trimble, a former leader of Northern Ireland’s Ulster Unionist party, a known supporter of Israel and a member of the recently launched “Friends of Israel” group. In 2007 Mr Trimble wrote a report for the Conservative Friends of Israel in the UK, explaining that the international community should oppose to negotiations with Hamas. You can read more on his appointment in NYT’s The Lede blog.

The second international observer is Canadian Brig. Gen. Ken Watkin, an expert on terrorism and on fighting none-governmental organizations. Terrorism experts usually back Israel.

This committee will probably not hear evidences from the passengers. It won’t be allowed to talk to IDF soldiers and officers, except for chief of staff Gabi Ashkenazi. To gain knowledge of the events on the Mavi Marmara, it will have to rely on the army’s report – if they even let the two observers to see it. Its report will deal with the legal justifications for the siege on Gaza and with the legitimacy of the Israeli raid.

The US has welcomed the commission. The rest of the world is doubtful, which is not surprising. It’s interesting to note that the Obama Administration, who supposedly believes working with in international institutions, helped Israel bypass a UN resolution (or at least try to: we don’t know what will happen with the UNHRC planned commission).

I think the administration is simply looking to put the entire affair behind it, and go back to the diplomatic game with the Palestinian Authority. Maybe the White House hopes to get some concessions out of Netanyahu for getting him and his government off the hook. Otherwise, I can’t imagine that they really take this probe seriously, and I even guess that’s the reason they didn’t put an American observer on it – so they don’t be part of the report which will find that Israel, believe it or not, did act within its rights. But if there is something that both the US and Israel needed to understand from the past two weeks, it’s that you can’t ignore Gaza, isolate Hamas and hope the problem will just go away or sort itself somehow. In fact, both should have learned that after Cast Lead. There won’t be half a peace, just in the West Bank. And even the flotilla incident is far from being over.


4 Comments on “Flotilla | A probe that would get Netanyahu’s government off the hook”

  1. 1 Yishai Kohen said at 8:53 pm on June 14th, 2010:

    Noam,

    At the end you write: “There won’t be half a peace, just in the West Bank.”

    The ONLY reason why it is relatively quiet here in Judea and Samaria is because we are here- and because in 2002 we (finally) went on the offensive, reconquered the terrorist hotbeds, hunted down the terrorists- and remained.

    In Gaza on the other hand, where every last Jew was ethnically cleansed, all soldiers left, what did the Philistines do? They immediately started shooting THOUSANDS of missiles at Israeli civilians, have constantly attempted to cross into the Negev to murder, kidnapped Gilad Shalit, and they elected Hamas to lead them.

    Peace is when WE rule OUR land- not when terrorists do.

    PS The flotilla incident IS over. Every day that passes it drops from the news more- and from peoples’ memories.

  2. 2 anonymous said at 9:49 pm on June 15th, 2010:

    Noam, you might want to read this article by a New York Times correspondent who worked in Israel. He puts some things in perspective that you should think about carefully.

    http://www.sfgate.com/cgi-bin/article.cgi?f=/c/a/2010/06/12/IN281DSQ0L.DTL

  3. 3 noam said at 11:25 pm on June 15th, 2010:

    anonymous: “puts things in perspective”? to me it seems his only argument is “come on, leave Israel alone”.

  4. 4 anonymous said at 10:56 pm on June 16th, 2010:

    No, he’s saying that the focus on Israel is entirely unreasonable, to the point of absurdity…or something else.