Injuries, tear gas in Nabi Saleh, record crowd in Sheikh Jarrah / Personal notes from Friday’s demonstrations

Posted: May 21st, 2010 | Author: | Filed under: elections, media, The Left, The Settlements, this is personal | Tags: , , , , , , , , , , | 7 Comments »
soldiers at Nabi Saleh

soldiers at Nabi Saleh

“Each Friday, there are at least 10 demonstrations involving Israelis and internationals in the West Bank,” tells me Didi Remez, as we drive to Nabi Saleh, the tiny village that has been fighting for months to regain access to a small spring that was taken over by settlers from nearby Halamish. Dozens of Israelis come to these protests, not counting the hundreds who arrive each Friday to Sheikh Jarrah in East Jerusalem.

Not much is going on when we arrive at Nabi Saleh. As we wait for the protesters to gather, we are offered lunch and cold water in a local house. Around 1.00 pm we join a small march down the village’s main street. Suddenly, three army jeeps appear and block the street, and about a dozen soldiers come out. About 25 protesters, most of them children and young girls, go all the way down to the soldiers, singing and shouting, accompanied by the photographers and the internationals. This goes on for about half an hour.

Then someone throws a stone. The soldiers respond with tear gas, lots of it. Together with a few other Israelis, I find shelter behind a local house. The wind carried the gas into the house and the old woman who lived there is now seating outside, tears running down her face. She signals me not to try and wash my face and instead just wait for the effect of the gas to fade.

The soldiers are chasing protesters into the village. Some of them occupy one of the houses, while the others fire tear gas from the street. Some of the nearby houses fill with gas, as their windows are broken from previous demonstrations. The Palestinians move to the upper part of the village, while the Israelis and internationals – who don’t take part in the stone throwing – are looking for safe corners, trying to avoid both the gas and the (very few) flying stones. Every now and then, the wind carries another cloud of gas towards our way.

The soldiers are shooting the gas cans directly at the protesters, and not in an arch, like I remember we were taught to do it in the army (you can see this in a these videos from a previous demonstration). Later, a Palestinian is injured after suffering a direct hit in his face.

After a couple of hours, we decide to leave the village (though the protest will go on almost till dusk). On the way back to the car, I see several boys, around the age of ten, falling to the ground, gasping for air after inhaling too much gas. Their faces are red and one of them is hardly breathing, but in a few minutes he recovers and rejoins the protesters.

A woman whose house was hit by tear gas

A woman whose house was hit by tear gas (p: Didi Remez)

By the time we get to Jerusalem, the protest on Shikh Jarrah is already on its way. The turnout is the best I’ve seen here: between 300 to 400 people. Without PR or money for busing, and after no less 30 protesters were arrested last week – somehow, it seemed that the protest is just getting bigger and bigger.

As Lisa Goldman notes, after Nabi Saleh, Jerusalem seems like a peaceful afternoon get-together. But for me it’s just as important, and I feel more at home here. Supporting the protest in the West Bank villages is crucial, but I find it emotionally hard to bear. After the last time I took part in it, it took me a full month to mount the strength to come again. To have soldiers point guns at me and fire tear gas is not only scary, but extremely strange. There is something in this experience that shakes my world. After all, I’m still an Israeli, and a reserve captain in the IDF for that matter!

I don’t take part in the stone throwing, but I definitely understand it and support the villagers in their struggle. Yet today in Nabi Saleh I asked myself from time to time what happens if the demonstration becomes more violent. What would I do – or feel – if a Molotov Cocktail is thrown?

I don’t have a good answer.

The protests in Jerusalem don’t carry such ideological and emotional problems. Ironically, the political message here is much more radical, since many Israelis who think we have nothing to do in Bilin or Nabi Saleh won’t like the idea of handing Sheikh Jarrah to the Palestinians, but the difference between the two events is unmistakable. Shikh Jarrah is an Israeli demonstration (with some Palestinians present); in the West Bank’s villages it’s the Palestinians who lead the action, and we are just guests. I find it fitting. I don’t expect many Israelis to come to Nabi Saleh to protest, but I do hope many will continue to take part in the demonstrations in Jerusalem, and that many others would join them.

Driving back from Jerusalem, this time with my mother, I was a bit encouraged. Recently, I’ve come to realize that Fridays in Sheikh Jarrah don’t feel like any other leftist event I’ve been to – and I had my share of them. Over the years, we had much bigger demonstrations, on much bigger issues – but something feels more real here, something even feels better. As if for the first time in years we are really doing exactly the right thing, and for the right reasons.

Protesters in Sheikh Jarrah

Protesters in Sheikh Jarrah

I forgot my camera today, so excuse the crappy photos taken on my phone. When I get better ones from one of the photographers who were with us, I will post them.

UPDATE: read Amitai Sandy’s account of the day’s protest in village of Maasra on comment #2.

7 Comments on “Injuries, tear gas in Nabi Saleh, record crowd in Sheikh Jarrah / Personal notes from Friday’s demonstrations”

  1. 1 rick said at 1:21 pm on May 21st, 2010:

    thanks a lot for sharing!

    my short thoughts (after reading lisa´s post, too)

    the sad thing is: the residents cant act in a civil way by f.e. calling the cops to stop the settler´s block of the spring. on the other hand by throwing stones they play in the hands of settlers (and the idf or border police, maybe) by turning the situation into a security treat.

    I like your idea of a civil right movement (you mentioned it in some blog posts) but here in this situation we´re allready faced with the inadequateness of this way.

  2. 2 Amitai Sandy said at 1:22 pm on May 21st, 2010:

    Here’s a short report from the demo in the village of Maasra, east of Efrata settelment.

    The demos in this village are usually much quieter, as the people of this village are much calmer. They don’t throw stones AT ALL.

    And yet, today, when we marched to the village’s entrance, and met with the soldiers, they had their plan ready in advance.

    They told us to get off the main road – we did exactly what they said. No violence, no stone throwing, no nonsense. The demonstrators decided to sit down on the road leading into the village, not blocking the main road AT ALL.

    So the we hear the commander tell his soldiers:
    “they’re gonna start throwing stones now, so you better start shooting gas.
    They did.
    Direct shooting, no arcs.

    All of us ran into the village, but that wasn’t enough for the soldiers.

    After arresting two Palestinians, they chased us into the village and continued shooting tear gas canisters, though non of us threatened them in any way, no stone throwing, no nothing. We were just running away from the tear gas canisters.

    The tear gas is no fun, but the effect wears off after a few minutes.

    But when shot directly, those canisters are as lethal as live ammo.

    Hassan, one of the demo’s organizers, was shot in the head with a tear gas canister.
    He’s in hospital now.

    If I was a beliver, I’d pray for his health. As an atheist, all I have left is hope.

    I met his and his brother’s kids today. They are so cute and smart. I climbed a mullberry (or some tree berry) tree with them today, and we ate the berries together. Their neighbor’s goat gave birth while we waited for news from the hospital.

  3. 3 rick said at 2:34 pm on May 21st, 2010:

    hey Amitai,

    thats a little different view. thanks for sharing!
    let me get one point right: Hassan as an organicer was specifically shot or “got hit” by a canister beeing at a wrong junction at the wrong time.

    I hope he´ll get well soon!

  4. 4 noam said at 1:04 am on May 22nd, 2010:

    Rick – the reality in the West bank is that the police and IDf view their job as protecting the settlers from the Palestinians, not the other way. It is all but useless to expect any help from them. it this video, you can see an army officer specifically says so to activist who tried to protest settlers’ violence.

    Regarding Nebi Saleh, as it happens, the village elders tried to do exactly what you offered. I even wrote about it after my previous visit to the village ( it didn’t help them, so they went back to demonstrating.

    While I don’t support violence and I won’t take part in stone throwing, one wonders what other option we leave the Palestinians.

  5. 5 Amitai Sandy said at 1:42 am on May 22nd, 2010:

    Rick – organizers and very active demonstrators are often specifically targeted with rubber coated metal bullets. I’m not sure how accurate the gas canister gun is, but at short range it might be possible to target people specifically.

    Palestinian reports claim the IOF tried new target seeking gas canisters, but I find it a little hard to believe.

  6. 6 Camilla said at 6:45 am on May 23rd, 2010:

    Hello Noam, thank you for this post. I have been reading you for a while, and I appreciate you a lot. I think that if one day things will go better it will be thanks people like you.

  7. 7 Nina Schafer said at 5:52 pm on May 27th, 2010:

    Really great article. Honest!